电影

没有和解

剧情  其它  1965 

状态:HD

主演:Heinrich Hargesheimer,Carlheinz Hargeshe

导演:让-马里·斯特劳布,达尼埃尔·于伊耶

自动配置

LZ线路

自动配置

FF线路

自动配置

WS线路

网友点评 · 107 人参与讨论

观众心声

吹牛伯爵

斯特劳布明显借鉴了布列松式的视听语言,画外的叙述者也随之几近更动,但恒久不变的是冷漠无情的克制语调。高度凝练的声轨、模特式的表演、高度简省的叙事及一丝不苟的构图风格体现在单镜头的段落中,人物进入这个空间,在其中做出各种动作与反应,或者进行语焉不详的简短交谈,最后走出空间,然而镜头仅仅是简单地注视空间,人物被客体化、物质化,空间叙事某种意义上替代了时间叙事,同时时间叙事的连续性与逻辑感也被斯特劳布悬置起来,自给自足的封闭空间由不断的溶、画外的噪声所打开,卸下电影艺术看似繁杂诱人的视听语言,取出“推”,“摇”作为唯一的镜头运动思路,从而将阐释的所有可能返还给观众。但不像布列松的超验风格,寻求着某种冥冥之中的他者在场,斯特劳布是一位绝对的唯物主义者。/二刷。镜头就是岩石。 2022.8.27

2022-12-07 有用 0
萌萌

将一战、二战、战后的情节重新剪辑,打破线性叙事,产生间离效果。闪回不提示时间,服装道具模糊时代,让观众混淆过去现在。但战争和暴力一直存在,展现德国历史的连续性。长子用军刀刺向圣母,暗示军国主义在一战已经存在。害死孙子的n粹凶手变成左翼政治明星,暗示暴力继续延续。教堂代表历史和信仰,被反复炸毁重建,历史成了一个轮回。教堂可以重建,亲人生命却已经消逝。上缴所有十字架,也无法换回天使的微笑。代表博爱的圣母被战争毁灭,和解无法消除暴力。总有人无法走出战争的阴影,面对延续的暴力,选择以暴制暴。当母亲拿出尘封已久的枪,就放弃了和解。羔羊代表民众,是救赎世界的希望,忍无可忍时也会踢人。虽然教堂被摧毁,但建设教堂的美好回忆仍然存在。结尾镜头转向窗外,在纯白镜头结束,暗示着德国的未来是光明和自由。

2024-05-14 有用 0
Rosemary

3.5 能看得出来对Nestler的影响 好像HS的作品反而需要从后往前看

2026-01-24 有用 0
马赛克

4.5; history as rupture, its traumas resurfacing in fractured time, where the dissonance of past and present unfolds in stark compositions and alienated performances, rejecting continuity, rejecting reconciliation - only the weight of unresolved violence remains

2025-02-20 有用 0
GrannyDog

60年代德国新青年电影,通过三代人的生活表现希特勒时代德国和战后德国现实对比。采用“布莱希特式”的戏剧风格与”间离效果”,注重文学化的台词,严肃庄重细腻,同时含有德国表现主义特点。“用历史的闪回镜头直接回顾了纳粹时期”。

2024-08-26 有用 0

故事梗概

  The subtitle of Jean-Marie Straub and Danièle Huillet’s first feature, from 1965, “Only Violence Helps Where Violence Reigns,” suggests the fierce political program evoked by their rigorous aesthetic. The pretext of the film, set in Cologne, is Heinrich Böll’s novel “Billiards at Half Past Nine,” which they strip down to a handful of stark events and film with a confrontational angularity akin to Bartók’s music that adorns the soundtrack. The subtlest of cues accompany the story’s complex flashbacks. The middle-aged Robert Fähmel tells a young hotel bellhop of persecutions under the Third Reich his elderly father, Heinrich, an architect famed for a local abbey, recalls the militarism of the First World War, when his wife, Johanna, incurred trouble for insulting the Kaiser. A third-generation Fähmel is considering architecture, just as the exiled brother of Robert’s late wife, returns, only to be met by their former torturer, now a West German official taking part in a celebratory parade of war veterans. Straub and Huillet make the layers of history live in the present tense, which they judge severely. The tamped-down acting and the spare, tense visual rhetoric suggest a state of moral crisis as well as the response—as much in style as in substance—that it demands.

网站地图 - 播放地图 - Tag地图返回顶部

本站只提供WEB页面服务,不提供影片录制和储存服务

若本站收录内容侵犯了贵公司权益

© 2026 午间影院